| Year | Result |
| 2073 | Calgary Stampeders 20, Murfreesboro Mules 17 |
| 2072 | Las Vegas Hookers 32, Calgary Stampeders 17 |
| 2071 | Murfreesboro Mules 24, Tijuana Tequila Worms 21 |
| 2070 | Madison Demons 23, Las Vegas Hookers 20 |
| 2069 | West Virginia Beasts 37, San Antonio Storm 27 |
| 2068 | Vancouver Killer Whales 33, West Virginia Beasts 20 |
| 2067 | San Antonio Storm 38, West Virginia Beasts 30 |
| 2066 | Houston Renegades 26, San Antonio Storm 24 |
| 2065 | Vancouver Killer Whales 46, Iowa City Tribe 24 |
| 2064 | Tijuana Tequila Worms 29, West Virginia Beasts 13 |
| 2063 | Murfreesboro Mules 37, Salt Lake City Stallions 10 |
| 2062 | Iowa City Tribe 24, Colorado Knights 23 |
| 2061 | Las Vegas Hookers 26, Vancouver Killer Whales 20 |
| 2060 | Tijuana Tequila Worms 34, Columbia Chicharrones 19 |
| 2059 | Vancouver Killer Whales 34, Iowa City Tribe 21 |
| 2058 | Tijuana Tequila Worms 28, Iowa City Tribe 21 |
| 2057 | Las Vegas Hookers 28, Vancouver Killer Whales 23 |
| 2056 | Hartford Whalers 34, Orlando Pirates 31 |
| 2055 | Vancouver Killer Whales 19, Portland (OR) Express 17 |
| 2054 | Calgary Stampeders 42, Iowa City Tribe 31 |
| 2053 | Vancouver Killer Whales 17, Miami Vice 13 |
| 2052 | Salt Lake City Stallions 31, Iowa City Tribe 27 |
| 2051 | Hartford Whalers 34, Salt Lake City Stallions 24 |
| 2050 | Hartford Whalers 45, Salt Lake City Stallions 21 |
| 2049 | Salt Lake City Stallions 27, Hartford Whalers 24 |
| 2048 | Georgia Generals 30, Iowa City Tribe 16 |
| 2047 | Los Angeles Matadors 23, Tijuana Tequila Worms 20 |
| 2046 | Tijuana Tequila Worms 37, Iowa City Tribe 30 |
| 2045 | Tijuana Tequila Worms 24, Alaska Polar Bears 20 |
| 2044 | Iowa City Tribe 43, Texas Bulldogs 19 |
| 2043 | Georgia Generals 42, Hartford Whalers 39 |
| 2042 | Houston Renegades 36, Texas Bulldogs 27 |
| 2041 | Houston Renegades 34, Dakota Spirit 14 |
| 2040 | Iowa City Tribe 31, Texas Bulldogs 10 |
| 2039 | Vancouver Killer Whales 28, Murfreesboro Mules 20 |
| 2038 | Miami Vice 13, Texas Bulldogs 10 |
| 2037 | Texas Bulldogs 17, Raleigh Armada 9 |
| 2036 | Tijuana Tequila Worms 31, Iowa City Tribe 16 |
| 2035 | Iowa City Tribe 30, Texas Bulldogs 26 |
| 2034 | Columbia Chicharrones 22, Texas Bulldogs 19 |
| 2033 | Texas Bulldogs 29, West Virginia Beasts 27 |
| 2032 | Iowa City Tribe 30, Calgary Stampeders 26 |
| 2031 | Iowa City Tribe 34, Vancouver Killer Whales 26 |
| 2030 | Salt Lake City Stallions 15, Alaska Polar Bears 13 |
| 2029 | Alaska Polar Bears 31, Dakota Spirit 26 |
| 2028 | Orlando Pirates 24, West Virginia Beasts 19 |
| 2027 | Georgia Generals 27, London Monarchs 14 |
| 2026 | State College Stagz 34, Texas Bulldogs 31 |
| 2025 | London Monarchs 23, Vancouver Killer Whales 20 |
| 2024 | Texas Bulldogs 35, Las Vegas Hookers 31 |
| 2023 | Boston Brawlers 27, State College Stagz 20 |
| 2022 | Boston Brawlers 24, Houston Renegades 6 |
| 2021 | Vancouver Killer Whales 19, West Virginia Beasts 17 |
| 2020 | Texas Bulldogs 23, West Virginia Beasts 20 |
| 2019 | Portland (OR) Express 10, Texas Bulldogs 3 |
| 2018 | State College Stagz 30, Boston Brawlers 27 |
| 2017 | Pittsburgh Pythons 40, Montreal Firebirds 16 |
| 2016 | Tijuana Tequila Worms 14, Portland (OR) Express 6 |
| 2015 | West Virginia Beasts 34, Tijuana Tequila Worms 27 |
| 2014 | West Virginia Beasts 41, San Antonio Storm 23 |
| 2013 | Boston Brawlers 28, Murfreesboro Mules 21 |
| 2012 | San Antonio Storm 41, State College Stagz 20 |
| 2011 | Boston Brawlers 24, Norfolk Fleet 21 |
| 2010 | Kansas City Owls 17, Iowa City Tribe 14 |
| 2009 | Hartford Whalers 19, Boston Brawlers 14 |
| 2008 | Norfolk Fleet 24, Madison Demons 7 |
| 2007 | McAllen Lancers 24, Norfolk Fleet 14 |
| 2006 | Norfolk Fleet 33, Calgary Stampeders 32 |
| 2005 | Miami Vice 13, McAllen Lancers 12 |
| 2004 | Madison Demons 19, Alaska Polar Bears 16 |
| 2003 | Orlando Pirates 24, State College Stagz 6 |